Rating: 4🌈
I have been waiting for Gavin Selby’s story since he made his appearance with his best friend in Briarwood Terrace, the old townhouse in Manhattan where he lives with Reid Marshall,owner of the nanny agency of the series.
Gavin’s quiet intensity, stately dress , and determined demeanor as well as hidden history just made even his briefest appearances objects of curiosity. The reader really wanted to know more about him. And the character Dash’s obvious crush on him, another ongoing thread, from book to book.
So I was prepared for an emotional and revelatory journey for the reader and Dash into Gavin’s past and the present. I expected the author’s usual excellent job of bringing Gavin’s entire story into the narrative forefront here so we could understand why he is the way he is. The trauma and damage he has endured to become the man who has allowed himself to become smaller inside, fearful, and alone. Boxed in emotionally by his father and events.
Sterling has been so outstanding at this in the past, but here, whether it is the nature of the situation or the holidays, we feel distanced from the causes of Gavin’s problems and past life. Even the threats, potential threats to his current life , are ephemeral, never feeling anywhere near substantial.
I think that’s because Gavin’s past, his father, any interactions he might have or had with him are on a “as told to” basis. That puts this entire situation and part of the story on a different perspective, one without any real immediate impact or emotional connection.
That’s unlike the evolving romance and relationship building up between himself and Dash. That’s sweet and sexy and vulnerable. It’s lovely watching these two grow and Gavin dare to love, especially at Christmas.
But it throws off the balance of the story because the other half is the secrets/ongoing conflicts with Gavin’s father. Which is done off page or through other sources or people. That’s taking away the power and the build up from this aspect of the plot.
At one point, I was just getting frustrated, thinking about how little was at the center core of all that secrecy. Especially when there’s all those powerful friends at hand.
So yes, sweet, sexy, loving romantic story but the entire plot itself was not a great success. A good one but not great. The romance and holiday season aspect was a delight. But the parts that centered around Gavin’s character and background didn’t really work. His past history, his family trauma, his father were all too distanced narratively from his storyline to make the impression that the story wants them to have.
Read it because the series is wonderful and you want Gavin’s story. And because it sets up the next and what is possibly the last of the series, Reid Marshall’s romance, One Night With The Nanny.
Nannies of New York :
✓ The Last Nanny In Manhattan #1
✓ Giles Ashby Needs A Nanny #2
✓ The Handy Nanny #3
✓ The Enchanting Nanny #4
✓ The Nanny with The Nice List #5
◦ One Night With The Nanny #6 – May 16, 2024
Buy Link:
The Nanny With The Nice List: Nannies of New York Book 5
Blurb:
This Christmas, Dash Griffin finally gets his man.
The library needs a new Santa to read stories to its littlest patrons and Dash has lots of friends who would be perfect. But instead of asking any of them, he sets his sights on quiet, uptight Gavin Selby. Dash has known for some time that the cranky accountant is the one for him. When he uncovers Gavin’s secret, Dash sees his chance to prove just how right they are for each other. Not only will Gavin become the library’s new Santa, but Dash is on a mission to deliver the brightest, most romantic Christmas ever.
Gavin has done everything in his power to protect his friends and paid a dear price. But he was happy to toe the line as long as everyone else got their happily ever after. Now, the price for Dash’s silence is pumpkin spice lattes and walks in Central Park. Gavin is happy to endure the holiday markets and wear a Santa costume if it means Dash will keep his secret. But can Gavin keep his most dangerous secret to himself? Or, will Dash finally discover that all Gavin wants for Christmas is him?
The Nanny with the Nice List is book 5 in the Nannies of New York series. It’s a sweet and steamy MM romance with lots of pining, a grumpy/sunshine pair, 10 year age gap and a sexual awakening. Plus, all the wonderful found family vibes that lovers of the Nannies in New York series know to expect.
*Paperback includes additional illustrations, playlists, bonus chapters, and more!
Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words 