
Rating: 4.75⭐️
Well, if that wasn’t just an excellent book. The mystery was one where you knew who did it after a while. But the investigation takes Blythe and her familiar, along with Anya, on a path that leads towards many places and players. So the plot winds up being poignant, character driven and layered with smaller pieces of other mysteries .
The author meaningfully scattered bits of information about the community throughout in new ways that knowledge of who did the murder early isn’t as key as you think.
And there’s another stranger mystery brewing that will lead to the next book in the series.
Sara Bourgeois is another autobuy/autoread for and this series is a great example why.
Highly recommended. Love the author.
Wicked Witches of Cauldron Hollow (4 book series)
If the Hat Fits #1
Under The Hat #2
Hat Out of Spell #3
Hat Trick #4
Bear Many Hats #5 – July 21,2026
Buy link
Hat Trick (Wicked Witches of Cauldron Hollow Book 4)
Blurb
Blythe Fairfield is finally getting the hang of her weird new life.
She owns a tea shop on Main Street. She’s dating the sheriff. Her late great-aunt’s notebooks are slowly teaching her what kind of witch she is, and her familiar has mostly stopped acting like tolerating her is a personal sacrifice.
Mostly.
Then the Cauldron Hollow Fall Festival rolls into town, and a dead body turns up behind the vendor trailers before the booths are even open.
The victim was a quiet leather worker traveling with the festival vendors. No enemies. No debts. No obvious connection to anyone in town.
At least, that’s the story everyone wants to tell.
As the festival barrels forward with tourists, bear sightings, and town gossip, Blythe starts tugging at threads nobody else seems to see. And somewhere between the funnel cake, fake smiles, and festival chaos, someone decides Blythe needs to stop asking questions.
Permanently.
It doesn’t help that Sheriff Paine is pulling away for reasons he refuses to explain. Or that Pippin keeps insisting being a Tallowmere should be enough to solve every problem, intimidate every enemy, and possibly improve Blythe’s posture.
But Cauldron Hollow has secrets it doesn’t show the tourists, and this one has been waiting twenty-four years to come due.
Blythe is about to learn there’s a big difference between a man running from his past and a man waiting for it to find him.
Sometimes the trick isn’t what’s in the hat.
It’s what’s been hidden in plain sight all along.
May 18, 2026
Language
English
Print length
218 pages
Book 4 of 5








