Rating: 4🌈
Samuel, fourth of the Regency Crofton Earl series, can be seen as a terrific companion story to his father’s book, Charles, as it’s events run simultaneously with those of that story.
Or if you prefer, as a standalone, since Cohen has done a marvelous job filling out the backstory of Charles and Timothy (Captain Thorne), both of whom are major characters here, as well as Aunt Amelia, and the rest of the foundation knowledge started in Charles.
There’s a topic that should be addressed in all the stories that often bothers some readers but it’s a common practice during this time period. That’s of taking sexual partners outside of the marriage, mostly because the marriages here are arranged by the families for reasons of politics and in their own royal interests . As long as they provide a heir or two, and their actions are discreet, other liaisons are likely and even expected. Some readers don’t want to read a book that has a “cheating “ element but historical fiction has parameters that make this quite difficult to follow. This story doesn’t try and it shouldn’t.
I enjoyed Samuel, not as much as I adore his father , Charles, but Samuel is definitely a man apart from the typical Redbourn in some respects. He’s less flamboyant, less aggressively dramatic, but against Charles, who could be?
Cohen instead builds layers of regret, pain, disappointment, and anger into Samuel. A man who’s had to deal with losses from his life, over and over. And without a support from the people who he needs most.
While I didn’t know Samuel well in his father’s book, we flip the perspective, and get a new sense of who this damaged man truly is. The drug fog he accepts rather than deal with the reality of the betrayal he’s just discovered, that’s believable.
It’s also an element that needs a trigger warning. A section of this story deals with drug addiction and withdrawal. If this is a trigger for you, please be aware.
The entire escapade with Charles working to create a wicked Earl scenario around Samuel? Priceless and very sexy. Loved this whole thread.
The only aspect of Samuel’s story I found lacking is Hugo Cavalier, the object of Samuel’s obsession and then love. Hugo is sort of there in the narrative for a couple of chapters. Then , he’s mentioned throughout as the one man Samuel can’t forget about. Then he reappears about 70 percent of the novel later, and , to my mind, Hugo never becomes a fully realized character.
Everyone else here is an animated, lively, breathing person, fully of personality. Yet Hugo remains sort of a one-note, beige person, one I cannot help but wonder why Samuel is so enthralled with.
That lack of chemistry, or two dimensional characterization keeps their relationship from truly mattering to me and this story from going from good to great.
It doesn’t help that there’s a fantastic couple there as comparison. Charles and Timothy are right there as couples goals, chemistry igniting, showing exactly why Samuel and Hugo come off as lacking.
But those parties! Oh my! Who wouldn’t want to be invited! So decadent, so delicious, so Redbourn!
I adored this!
Yes, I’m recommending Samuel, it’s great to see that family again and see how it all plays out. While not a huge fan of Hugo, I am of the rest! There’s a new modern Crofton on it’s way so enjoy the Regency era now!
The Crofton Universe :
🔷The Crofton Chronicles–Historical (Elizabethan/ Early Stuart):
✓ The Actor and the Earl
✓ Duty to the Crown
✓ Forever Hold His Peace
✓ The Love and the Anger Historical (Elizabethan/ Early Stuart)–Sebastian/ Anthony 10 years together
🔷The Earls of Crofton–Historical: (Different eras–can be read as individual standalone novels):
✓ Anthony, Earl of Crofton (Early Stuart)
✓ James, Earl of Crofton (Restoration)
✓ Charles, Earl of Crofton (Regency)
✓ Samuel, Earl of Crofton (Regency)
🔷The Modern Crofton–Contemporary:
✓ Saving Crofton Hall
✓ Making History at Crofton Hall
✓ Below Stairs at Crofton Hall
✓ Getting Married at Crofton Hall
✓ Starting Again at Crofton Hall
â—¦ Coming Out at Crofton Hall- TBD
🔷Standalones in the Crofton Universe
â—¦ Much Ado About Lady Macbeth Note: Sebastian Hewel is a minor character
Something extra for Crofton! Modern Crofton Short Story:
â—¦ Ben and the Mistletoe (set the Christmas after Saving Crofton Hall)
Buy Link:
Description:
Only the selected few get to attend the special evenings hosted by Samuel Redbourn, 9th Earl of Crofton, the Hellcat of the Ton.
Despite his reputation, Samuel is not the man everyone thinks he is. He has lost a lot in his young life, and after recovering from his addiction to laudanum, it’s time to make the Ton take notice. There’s one thing he wants above all, Hugo, the only man he’s ever loved. But Hugo Cavalier was sent away by his father after he was caught in bed with Samuel, and when he returns to England several years later, there is no guarantee they can rekindle what they once had.
Historical gay Regency romance. A standalone novel in the Crofton Universe.
Please note: contains scene of period drug use, addiction, and recovery.
Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words 